While it may've been written with the best intentions in mind, I personally believe that we must first determine what the people of Barbuda (as a micro community) - and by extension the nationals of the entire twin-island state (as a macro entity) really want. I believe that the regional or international community projecting our economic ideals on a ravaged nation is a bit inconsiderate and inappropriate. I'm not opposed to developing Barbuda into an advanced entity, but I am hesitant in suggesting that it should be a "Modern Tourist City".
In post-volcanic Montserrat, there has been a considerable amount of contention in the notion of developing the proposed new, capital city of Little Bay into a tourism-centre. Local residents, diaspora, expats, and visitors all have varying opinions on what the island should be, and should evolve into. The concept of competing with other islands who's tourism sectors are more established, is not an appealing thought for some. Meanwhile, others welcome the idea of expanding Montserrat's reach into the global market. Many still believe that Montserrat should target niche areas of tourism - focusing on low numbers, but high spenders. Others however, still hold firm that we should be increasing our visitor arrivals on an annual basis.
As I mentioned before, as an Architect who's interest is in development, I would eagerly support the opportunity to improve the Barbudan environment. However, we must be sensitive to the inhabitants and ensure that when this island is developed it still has the Barbudan cultural identity EMBEDDED within the domain. A "modern tourism city" only creates a replica of so many different towns within the region. It is at this critical point, when the impact of globalization should be carefully considered.
Each island within the Caribbean has it's own charm and uniquely enticing environment for tourists. Barbuda's enthrall may very well be the very aspect that some developers could be seeking to change.
"Luxury resorts" and high-end commercial environments tend to encourage a divide between the 'haves and have-nots' in a community - potentially impacting crime rates, and motivating gentrification. As professionals within the built environment, it is our responsibility to ensure that when we develop, it is not merely because we have been placed an "almost virginal" canvas before us - but instead, to shape spaces and create communities that are for the people.
This is our social responsibility.
The article from the Jamaica Observer, is below:
http://www.jamaicaobserver.com/editorial/barbuda-2-0-rebuild-devastated-island-into-a-modern-tourist-city_110643?profile=1100
No comments:
Post a Comment